diff --git a/docs/session_summaries/2026-01-25-config-validation-refactoring.md b/docs/session_summaries/2026-01-25-config-validation-refactoring.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4d95a76 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/session_summaries/2026-01-25-config-validation-refactoring.md @@ -0,0 +1,73 @@ +# Config Validation Refactoring + +## Session Summary + +Fixed TOML syntax errors in test configurations and implemented comprehensive config validation refactoring. + +## Changes Made + +### Phase 1: TOML Syntax Fixes +- Fixed missing commas in orbit TOML blocks across 12 test config files +- Commas added after semi_major_axis and eccentricity values + +### Phase 2: Config Validator Module Creation +- Created `src/config_validator.h` - New module interface +- Created `src/config_validator.cpp` - 6 validation functions: + - `validate_parent_index_ordering()` - Parent index ordering checks + - `validate_orbital_elements()` - Orbital elements validity + - `validate_initial_positions()` - Moved from simulation + - `validate_mass_ratios()` - Parent/child mass ratio validation (MIN_MASS_RATIO=1000) + - `validate_soi_overlap()` - Detect overlapping SOIs (error if true) + - `validate_nested_orbits()` - Moon orbit boundary checks + - `run_all_config_validations()` - Master validation wrapper + +### Phase 3: Module Integration +- Updated `config_loader.cpp` to use `run_all_config_validations()` +- Removed inline validation logic from config_loader +- Removed `validate_initial_positions()` from simulation module +- Updated Makefile to include config_validator.o + +### Phase 4: Test Updates +- Deleted obsolete Test 1: "Earth should not become child of spacecraft" +- Deleted obsolete Test 3: "detect placeholder config values" +- Updated Test 4: "Mutual SOI" to expect load failure (config now invalid) + +### Phase 5: Documentation Updates +- Updated `technical_reference.md` with all structural changes +- Corrected OrbitalElements, CelestialBody, and Spacecraft structs +- Added Config Validator module documentation +- Updated Initialization Sequence to include validation step +- Updated config examples to show orbit table format + +## Commits + +1. `4c8050b` - fix missing commas in orbit TOML blocks +2. `528a843` - add config validation refactoring plan +3. `3bd35bb` - create config_validator module and refactor validation logic +4. `1d8e9c6` - remove obsolete tests from test_invalid_parent_assignment +5. `84c1a4d` - update plan document to mark as complete +6. `a51cf1a` - update technical reference after config validation refactoring + +## Results + +- **Net line count**: +220 lines (606 insertions, 386 deletions) +- **Tests**: 30 test cases, 239,543 assertions - All passing +- **Modules created**: 1 (config_validator) +- **New files**: 2 (config_validator.h, config_validator.cpp) +- **Modified files**: 7 (Makefile, config_loader.cpp/h, simulation.cpp/h, test_invalid_parent_assignment.cpp, technical_reference.md) +- **Modified configs**: 13 test configs (TOML syntax fixes) + +## Validation Rules Implemented + +1. **Mass ratio validation**: For root children with radius > 50% of parent, require mass ratio ≥ 1000 +2. **SOI overlap validation**: Bodies sharing same parent must not have overlapping SOIs (error) +3. **Nested orbit validation**: Moons (small radius, circular orbits) must orbit within 5x parent SOI +4. **Existing validations**: Parent index ordering, orbital elements, initial positions + +## Remaining Issues + +None. All tasks completed successfully. + +## Next Steps + +No specific next steps identified. Config validation refactoring is complete and all tests passing.