Browse Source

Update future work doc - reference Newton-Raphson plan and stability findings

main
cinnaboot 5 months ago
parent
commit
927a8d2027
  1. 54
      docs/future_work.md

54
docs/future_work.md

@ -26,32 +26,38 @@ This document outlines planned enhancements and future development areas for the
- Add validation tests for energy/momentum conservation - Add validation tests for energy/momentum conservation
- Consider relative velocity of parent bodies - Consider relative velocity of parent bodies
### More Accurate Integration Methods ### Newton-Raphson Analytical Propagation
**Current:** RK4 (Runge-Kutta 4th order) integration **Current:** RK4 (Runge-Kutta 4th order) numerical integration
**Proposed:** Newton-Raphson propagation for higher precision **Proposed:** Newton-Raphson analytical propagation with hybrid burn handling
**Status:** Implementation plan created - see `docs/newton_raphson_propagation_plan.md`
**Benefits:** **Benefits:**
- Improved accuracy for long-term orbit predictions - Time steps of hours/days (vs. seconds/minutes with RK4)
- Better handling of near-parabolic trajectories - 60-2880x performance improvement depending on orbit scale
- Perfect 2-body accuracy with no numerical drift
**Implementation Considerations:** - Newton-Raphson converges in 3-5 iterations
- May require adaptive timestep sizing
- More complex than RK4 **Implementation Approach:**
- Trade-off between accuracy and performance - Analytical propagation for orbital motion (99% of simulation time)
- RK4 integration during finite-duration burns (1% of time)
### Io and Titan Orbital Stability Tuning - Seamless transitions between modes
**Issue:** Outer solar system moons exhibit orbital drift - SOI transitions with orbital element transformations
**Approaches:** **Estimated Effort:** 30-44 hours across 5 implementation phases
- Reduced timestep for moon systems
- Specialized local frame handling ### Orbital Stability Validation
- Higher precision for distant parent-body interactions **Status:** Time step stability analysis complete
- Moon-specific integration parameters
**Findings (from `tests/informational/test_time_step_stability`):**
**Validation:** - RK4 at 60s is very stable (22% of stability limit)
- Long-term stability tests (> 100 orbits) - Mercury orbiter (MESSENGER-like) is limiting factor: 270s max stable dt
- Energy conservation metrics - Io and Moon are very stable (>596s max stable dt)
- Orbital period accuracy verification - Current default (60s) provides excellent margin
**Documentation:** See `tests/informational/README.md` for test details and results
**Conclusion:** No stability tuning needed - RK4 works well for moon systems with existing dt=60s default
## Visualization Enhancements ## Visualization Enhancements

Loading…
Cancel
Save